Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (2024)

You are here: Home / Recipes / Breakfast / Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe

2 · · 30 Comments

Two times of the day that can be a little hairy at our house are breakfast and after school. The kiddos are hungry and they are looking for whatever isn’t nailed down to eat. If not careful, they will eat their body weight in junk and empty calories. One trick I have is to make sure to have healthy, tasty alternatives ready at hand. One of my secret weapons is a super rich and extra creamy yogurt cups with granola, berries and drizzled with a bit of agave. I keep these tasty little cups on hand in the fridge for the kiddos to easily grab for a healthy, satisfying breakfast or after-school snack.

I know this isn’t a new concept at all but what makes it a little different and super economical is the way I make the yogurt extra special. Instead of buying the more expensive individual cups or even the creamy and a little more decadent Greek yogurt, I buy the cheaper low-fat or fat-free vanilla yogurt that you can purchase in large containers. This is then where the magic a happens…

Here is what you will need…

  • Large container of your favorite yogurt
  • Fresh or frozen berries
  • Granola
  • Agave nectar or honey
  • Small containers in which to store individual portions of the tasty treat {optional}

I pour all of the yogurt in to a mesh strainer lined with a paper towel and let that sit in the fridge for a few hours.

This drains some of the excess liquid from the yogurt and makes it extra decadent and creamy. My kids LOVE it! I top it with berries, granola and then drizzle a little Agave nectar over it and they couldn’t be happier. I store the creamy yogurt in small jars in the fridge so that the kiddos can run and grab one anytime they like!

What are some of your healthy treat options for your kiddos? What tricks do you employ to get them to crave healthy foods?

2

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (7)Bonnie @ Uncommon says

    These just look delicious!! Thank you for sharing! They are very pretty too! We are big yogurt fans and I have to try this one! Bonnie 😉

    Reply

  2. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (8)Amanda says

    Looks delish! Thanks for sharing!

    Reply

  3. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (9)Tonia @The Gunny Sack says

    How cool! The creamier the better when it comes to yogurt so I love this idea!!

    Reply

  4. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (10)nitasha says

    Yum! love this idea and love your little containers….where can i get those?

    Reply

  5. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (11)Angie@Echoes of Laughter Blog says

    Hi Heather! This looks so good and your pictures are fabulous! I love your blog…so full of wonderful inspiration! I don’t always comment, but I am here everyday! I, too, love mason jars! Last week I made a layered salad and shared it on my blog! Have a wonderful day! Angie xo

  6. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (12)Haley K says

    Brilliant! i love my yogurt extra creamy 🙂 And this could help make the low calorie kind a little more rich…thanks for the idea! xo

    Reply

  7. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (13)crissy k says

    Hey Heather do you mix the fruit and granola in before you put it into the fridge? sounds so yummy

    Reply

  8. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (15)Mrs EJ says

    Looks lovely! Actually, this is a very simple way of making Greek yogurt. What makes that so creamy anyway is the absence of whey. So when you strain it from your regular yogurt, you’re left with creamy goodness.

    Reply

  9. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (17)Kelley Wilson says

    oh my gosh this looks so good, I don’t know if you have but would you PLEASE do a post on your beautiful photography and how to do it?

    Reply

  10. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (18)Heather says

    I LOVE this idea – will have to try with our homemade yogurt (not as thick but delicious)

    Gorgeous pictures!

    Reply

  11. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (20)Tammy says

    What a great idea! We all love yogurt at our house. I’ll have to try this.

    Reply

  12. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (21)Melinda Redmann says

    Great idea to pre-package a good snack! Your jars are darling! Can I ask where you found them? Thank you for the great idea!

    Reply

  13. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (22)Stephanie says

    Your pics are great. My kids eat this regularly and call it “yougurt surprise” because they never know what type of fruit or crunch (granola, nuts, cereal) that they will be getting. I like your idea of serving it up in single portion cups ready to go. Makes it much easier on the kids, for sure.

    Also, the liquid from you yougurt is whey and it’s super nutritious and valuable. The Prairie Homestead recently posted a piece about different ways to use your whey.
    http://www.theprairiehomestead.com/2011/06/16-ways-to-use-your-whey.html

    Thanks for sharing!

    Reply

  14. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (23)Theresa says

    I’ll have to try this! Looks yummy!

    Reply

  15. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (24)Heather says

    DELICIOUS! Thanks for sharing!

    Reply

  16. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (25)sarah says

    I am going to use this idea for a bridal shower! thanks!

    Reply

  17. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (26)Leona says

    This looks awesome, I love yogurt and berries so I’ll be making this. thanks for a great tip.

    Reply

  18. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (27)Csue says

    You can make your own yogurt with a crockpot and it is so simple. I use my 6 quart crock pot and heat up 5 quarts of milk for 2 hours on low. Unplug the crock pot and let the milk cool to 110 degrees, add 1 1/4 cups of greek style plain yogurt you bought at the store and whisk it in really good. Put the lid back on, wrap the crock pot up in a nice warm blanket and let it incubate for 8-15 hours. The longer it incubates the thicker and creamier the end product is. The whey needs to be drained just like in this post. Line a colander with cheese cloth and pour the yogurt in. Gather the ends together and let the whey drip out as it hangs from a cabinet, faucet etc. Let drain about 2 hours unless you want it creamier. Now you have plain yogurt and you can mix in whatever you want. You can also use and immersion blender to make it nice and smooth. Our favorite sweetener is honey and vanilla extract. My kids LOVE this!!

    Reply

  19. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (28)Tartine says

    Hi heather, I just started following your blog, really love it! That’s a great idea! My kids love yogurt, but a lot of brands have added stuff in it that I don’t want. I love Csue yogurt recipe, and will it a try too!

    Reply

  20. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (29)katherine says

    this looks so unique, i second the question; where did you purchase the containers?

    Reply

    • Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (30)katherine says

      just found the jars, they are ball 4 oz quilted pattern.

      Reply

  21. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (31)Florencia Lovardo says

    You can have the same Greek yoghurtwith less work following this isntructions. I prepare in different glass jars small porcions of fruit salad. Add some honey or sweetener and on top and nuts,almonds or what ever (even dried fruit) The natural healthy bacterias that the yoghurt has will develop and you will get an excellent Greek yogurt with no other work. I do it at night and have it ready for breakfast or even my son takes to school as a snack. Sometimes he adds granola at the moment he will eat it. I just prepare once some ammount of jars and is always a new taste for I add to the same plain yogurt vainilla flavour, some strawberries, bananas,kiwis, dried prunes, and sometimes even home made mermalade. Thank You for sharing. Sharing is caring.

    Reply

  22. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (32)Jen says

    You are brilliant! Greek yogurt is SO much more expensive! And, the only difference is that it's just more solid (less liquid). So, by straining the "cheaper" stuff, you're saving yourself tons of money! =)

    Reply

  23. Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (33)Kim says

    This sounds great Does any one know where I can get the carbs,protein, fat etc…….I had heard there is a site that you type in all ingredients for a receipe and it will tell you all the nutrition info…….can any one help me please?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Extra Creamy Yogurt Cups | Recipe (2024)

FAQs

How to make yogurt thicker? ›

STRAIN THE YOGURT

Straining the yogurt removes some of the water content (whey), leaving the fats and proteins behind. The longer you drain away whey, the thicker your yogurt will become. Removing all the whey will result in a thick probiotic yogurt cream cheese.

What can I add to yogurt to make it more filling? ›

Other Yogurt Bowl Topping Ideas

Try this blueberry peach yogurt bowl. Dried fruit – raisins, cranberries, dates, cherries. Nuts and seeds – almonds, pecans, walnuts, pistachios, sunflower seeds, pepitas (aka pumpkin seeds) chia seeds, flax seeds, hemp seeds.

How do you thicken yogurt for dessert? ›

Here are some agents recommended by google as a good way to thicken yogurt:
  1. Milk Solids. ...
  2. Adding gelatin to milk before heating and culturing. ...
  3. Pectin.
  4. Agar.
  5. Guar Gum.
  6. Tapioca Starch.
  7. Arrowroot Starch.
  8. Ultra-Gel (modified corn starch)

Can heavy cream be used to make yogurt? ›

It's easy to make your own yogurt, and it can be quite different from the yoghurt you can buy in the store.

Does yogurt get thicker the longer you cook it? ›

If you heat the milk to 195°F / 90°C and hold it there for ten minutes, the yogurt will be milder and thicker when it sets, and will have a bit more of a cooked milk taste. What is the reason for holding the temperature at 195°F / 90°C for ten minutes using the “High-Low” method?

How do they make Greek yogurt so thick? ›

Greek yogurt is just what you get when you take regular yogurt, plop it in some fine mesh cloth, and allow some of the liquid in it—whey, to be more precise—to slowly drain out, resulting in a thicker yogurt with less moisture.

How to add more volume to yogurt? ›

Adding dry milk powder also increases the volume of yogurt you get out of one batch. My recipe yields just shy of 3 quarts of yogurt from a single half-gallon of milk. Dry milk powder is resistant to hydrating. You can't just dump it into the milk, or you will end up with a clumpy mess.

How do you improve the consistency of yogurt? ›

Here are a few ways you can thicken your yogurt.
  1. Strain out whey until desired consistency. ...
  2. Add powdered milk/unflavored gelatin/pectin/tapioca starch to your mixture and ferment like usual. ( ...
  3. Increase the fat content by either adding 1/2 & 1/2 or heavy cream. ...
  4. Use whole fat milk.

How do you spruce up yogurt? ›

How to Make Plain Greek Yogurt Taste Good: 10 easy tips
  1. Add fresh fruit.
  2. Add frozen fruit.
  3. Mix with canned pumpkin and spices.
  4. Drizzle with honey or maple syrup.
  5. Mix with nuts or seeds.
  6. Blend into a smoothie.
  7. Add cereal.
  8. As a marinade.
Feb 17, 2023

Can you add cornstarch to yogurt? ›

"Pure yogurt is quite soft and watery. This recipe adds gelatine and cornstarch like most store-bought brands. The result is a velvety smooth, thick creamy yogurt."

How do you thicken non dairy yogurt? ›

Thickeners for vegan yogurt. Tapioca starch: If you add tapioca starch directly to the milk, it will form a clumpy mess. Instead, create a slurry by combining ½ cup milk and 2 tablespoons tapioca starch in a small bowl. Mix until smooth, then add the mixture back to the saucepan.

What happens when you add gelatin to yogurt? ›

Add Gelatin – A little gelatin helps make yogurt surprisingly creamy and thick (though too much and you'll get yogurt jello!). Start experimenting with one teaspoon of gelatin per quart of milk. Mix it in a bowl with a little milk and let it bloom. Then stir into the pot of milk as it starts to heat.

What can you add to yogurt to make it thick? ›

DIFFERENT YOGURT THICKENERS & HOW TO USE THEM
  1. Milk Solids. Powdered milk solids generally come in cow, goat, and soy varieties. ...
  2. Gelatin. When to Add: Add to milk before heating and culturing. ...
  3. Pectin. ...
  4. Agar. ...
  5. Guar Gum. ...
  6. Tapioca Starch. ...
  7. Arrowroot Starch. ...
  8. Ultra-Gel (modified corn starch)
May 31, 2023

Can I use full cream milk to make yogurt? ›

I prefer whole milk, both for yogurt and, well, life, but you can use 2%, 1%, or skim, as well. They all work. Some folks like to bulk up leaner milks with some dry nonfat milk powder (roughly from 1/3 to 3/4 cup powder per quart of milk) to thicken it, especially in the absence of luscious dairy fat.

Can I substitute heavy whipping cream for Greek yogurt? ›

When you really need to thicken a dish, Greek yogurt gets the job done — in fact, it's much thicker than heavy cream. Combine equal parts Greek yogurt and milk for a substitute closer to heavy cream's thickness. Be sure to add it while your dish is off the heat to avoid curdling, and don't use it for whipping.

How do you fix runny yogurt? ›

Here are a few ways you can thicken your yogurt.
  1. Strain out whey until desired consistency. ...
  2. Add powdered milk/unflavored gelatin/pectin/tapioca starch to your mixture and ferment like usual. ( ...
  3. Increase the fat content by either adding 1/2 & 1/2 or heavy cream. ...
  4. Use whole fat milk.

Can I strain yogurt to make it thicker? ›

Pour the processed yogurt into the lined strainers and let it sit 1-2 hours. You can leave it on the counter top or place in the refrigerator. Once the yogurt is at the consistency that you prefer, transfer the yogurt to another bowl. The longer you strain, the thicker it will be.

How to add volume to yogurt? ›

Many recipes call for ~1/2 cup (60g) per half-gallon of milk. I mistakenly added more than twice this amount one time and found it made something that didn't need straining at all, and it's been my go-to method ever since. Adding dry milk powder also increases the volume of yogurt you get out of one batch.

What gives yogurt its thickness? ›

The thickness of the yogurt results from the coagulated proteins determined by the fat content of the milk, the yogurt starter, and amount of milk solids (protein). Adding nonfat milk powder (milk solids) to cold milk before heating will result in a firmer yogurt.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Greg Kuvalis

Last Updated:

Views: 6185

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Greg Kuvalis

Birthday: 1996-12-20

Address: 53157 Trantow Inlet, Townemouth, FL 92564-0267

Phone: +68218650356656

Job: IT Representative

Hobby: Knitting, Amateur radio, Skiing, Running, Mountain biking, Slacklining, Electronics

Introduction: My name is Greg Kuvalis, I am a witty, spotless, beautiful, charming, delightful, thankful, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.